NP Elzbieta and Dr Carpentier guided me from preconception care to placing me in the best hands for endometriosis surgery with Dr Sticco, and now throughout pregnancy as we are…NP Elzbieta and Dr Carpentier guided me from preconception care to placing me in the best hands for endometriosis surgery with Dr Sticco, and now throughout pregnancy as we are expecting our first baby boy! I am forever grateful for their exceptional care and dedication to improving patient outcomes.Fertility clinic
Gianna Center - Manhattan
Melville, NY · Long Island · Long Island · (516) 705-1148
- Website
- catholichealthli.org
- Phone
- (516) 705-1148
- Location
- Melville, NY · Long Island

Patient reviews
Excerpts come from public listings. Show more reveals the excerpt stored here; the original source has the full review.
21 excerpts on this page21 Google reviews
I spoke with the receptionist Rebeca from Giana Center over the phone. She had previously given me the Catholic Health phone number. I called back about ten minutes later to…I spoke with the receptionist Rebeca from Giana Center over the phone. She had previously given me the Catholic Health phone number. I called back about ten minutes later to confirm something, and when she answered, she did not identify herself. When I asked if it was Rebeca, she didn’t confirm and simply replied, “How can I help?” in a curt tone. I found her response unprofessional and rude, which made me feel uncomfortable. I hope the clinic provides additional training for its front desk staff so that patients feel treated with kindness and respect.Got read a Bible verse and told I can’t have fertility testing despite a well documented endometriosis diagnosis because I am not married. To add insult to injury, I’m an…Got read a Bible verse and told I can’t have fertility testing despite a well documented endometriosis diagnosis because I am not married. To add insult to injury, I’m an employee. Deplorable. Don’t waste your time if you are already frustrated by a difficult diagnosis - this will only upset you more.The entire staff here at the Gianna Center especially Dr. Carpentier and Erika have been nothing but amazing. From the day I came in March 2024 until now they helped me get…The entire staff here at the Gianna Center especially Dr. Carpentier and Erika have been nothing but amazing. From the day I came in March 2024 until now they helped me get through a tough time and helped me where I am now to conceive a baby naturally. They have been very attentive and thorough throughout the whole process and all their support and guidance and became educated on the whole process. I am very thankful Dr. C. I highly recommend them to families or women who are going through anything they will help you. Thank you, guys, for everything.The entire Gianna Center staff is not only extremely competent, but also incredibly caring. The sanctity of human life is truly reverenced and that is not something that you can…The entire Gianna Center staff is not only extremely competent, but also incredibly caring. The sanctity of human life is truly reverenced and that is not something that you can find in many areas of medicine. Very grateful to be under their care, don’t know if some of my children would exist without them!So grateful for my babies and the Gianna center for figuring out my issues. Would be 5 stars except they are telling women to get the covid injection. These are women who are…So grateful for my babies and the Gianna center for figuring out my issues. Would be 5 stars except they are telling women to get the covid injection. These are women who are often already struggling with infertility and miscarriage and this doctor is saying to inject more crap into the body. So disappointed.Dr. Carpentier is one of a kind- and a dying breed. No physician out there cares as much as he does… he is wholeheartedly in this field to help men and women achieve their goals…Dr. Carpentier is one of a kind- and a dying breed. No physician out there cares as much as he does… he is wholeheartedly in this field to help men and women achieve their goals of finally having a family, while also helping to improve health and wellness of his patients. And in the most natural ways possible! I struggled with years of infertility. I had numerous doctors tell me I would never conceive naturally. I found Dr C and within about 4-5 months… I FINALLY was pregnant… naturally! Then we experienced multiple miscarriages. From there, Dr C. helped me to realize my diagnosis of PCOS & endometriosis, which lead me to a successful laparoscopy with Dr. Peter Sticco…. 6 months later, we conceived with our first born! From the beginning to the end…. I am endlessly thankful to the work of Paul Carpentier & his amazing team. Special mentions to Joyce, Jaime, Barbara, Elizabeta… and to the many wonderful NPs & nurses I didn’t mention… you all always kept my hope alive. Your warm approach, caring demeanors and endless encouragement is honestly what made me keep going. I’ll forever look at my daughter and remember you all when I do! With endless thanks & appreciation, The Vieira FamilyI have to take the time to write a review about Dr. Carpentier. He is truly the most empathetic doctor I have ever met and sat with. He takes time to listen and educate (over an…I have to take the time to write a review about Dr. Carpentier. He is truly the most empathetic doctor I have ever met and sat with. He takes time to listen and educate (over an hour!) He does not make you feel rushed or like there is anywhere else he has to be. To Dr. C, for that hour, you are all that matters. Throughout my entire appointment I kept telling my husband I felt like I was in a dream. He does not dismiss your concerns or symptoms. I have been to numerous doctors who have dismissed my symptoms or concerns telling me they are not related. He is the first doctor to actually listen and confirm that they all fit together in a puzzle. He is the first doctor to treat my symptoms instead of what my previous “normal” tests showed. I would truly recommend him to any woman going through reoccurring miscarriages. For the first time in a year I see a light at the end of the tunnel for my rainbow baby. 🤍🌈My experience with the Gianna center was extremely upsetting. The staff was wonderful, and while Dr. Carpentier’s bedside manner was appreciated, there were inappropriate moments…My experience with the Gianna center was extremely upsetting. The staff was wonderful, and while Dr. Carpentier’s bedside manner was appreciated, there were inappropriate moments that were brought up. For one thing, it was intimated that a certain medication that he had available could’ve prevented several miscarriages I had. This was an inappropriate statement in my opinion, as if that were true, this medication would be widely available and taken by everyone. I was also met with discussions about politics (in particular, why Donald Trump was wonderful and responsible for certain birth control methods). Regardless of political affiliation, I do not find it appropriate to bring politics into medical conversations. I was also asked about my fertility prospects (whether I wanted more children) while sitting in the office with a newborn and dealing with some postpartum issues. I did not broach the topic independently, and found the conversation to be inappropriate considering the type of care I was seeking at the moment. He also said that my thyroid was in need of medical supplementation, while the results indicated that my thyroid was perfectly normal. Needless to say, I will not be seeking care from this provider in the near future.Dr C is the most patient and thoughtful doctor ever. He is always offering wise, holistic yet scientific solutions. He genuinely cares about his patients and does not rush. I…Dr C is the most patient and thoughtful doctor ever. He is always offering wise, holistic yet scientific solutions. He genuinely cares about his patients and does not rush. I cannot recommend him enough.Dr.Carpentier. He is truly the most empathetic and compassionate doctor I have ever met. He truly cares about patients and he always takes his time to listen to everything that I…Dr.Carpentier. He is truly the most empathetic and compassionate doctor I have ever met. He truly cares about patients and he always takes his time to listen to everything that I have to said. I have never felt rushed and if I need anything all I need to do is call the office or message him. All the staff are very helpful and empathetic, I have never seen and office that all the staff are so helpful, friendly and compassionate.highly highly recommend this Doctor and office.❤️I have endo one doctor was able to diagnose however back in 2016 it was still new so treatment wasnt easy went here and the dr specialized in it knows his stuff and filled me in…I have endo one doctor was able to diagnose however back in 2016 it was still new so treatment wasnt easy went here and the dr specialized in it knows his stuff and filled me in more than the 6yrs ive been dealing with it in one shot. Thankful for them highly recommend!Great stuff and very welcoming. The receptionist was very nice , the nurse that took my information was a nice lady , very delicate and did an amazing job. The nurse that did my…Great stuff and very welcoming. The receptionist was very nice , the nurse that took my information was a nice lady , very delicate and did an amazing job. The nurse that did my ultrasound was very respectful and was doing her job very professionally. The doctor from Where should I start ?! … he was such a great person he took time to make me relax , he answered all my question as first time mom , he help me with vitamins and recommended me better vitamins to prevent any kind of problem to my baby . Such a great team I recommend to all the woman that are scare and wants to make sure their baby is doing great in a early pregnancy. Loved that place thanks so much God bless all of you !!!This office is full of happiness and kindness the whole staff will make you feel like your at home. The doctors and nurses here are all amazing they make your problems their…This office is full of happiness and kindness the whole staff will make you feel like your at home. The doctors and nurses here are all amazing they make your problems their problems ! They will take you seriously and guide you through your journey ! I was not getting pregnant from pass 5years but thanks Dr.Carpentier he did help me told me what multivitamins I needed to take and I got pregnant now finally if it wasn’t for him today I don’t know what I would do I would loose hope ! Please do not hesitate to come see this doctor he will change your life ! Joyce is so amazing she always made sure my appointments were made on time not too late receptionist for the front desk you will love this place !Dr. Carpentier is AMAZING! I owe my children to him! No other doctor was able to help me conceive or treat my endometriosis like him. Office is an incredibly caring and…Dr. Carpentier is AMAZING! I owe my children to him! No other doctor was able to help me conceive or treat my endometriosis like him. Office is an incredibly caring and comfortable environment. They make you feel like family. For anyone struggling with fertility and haven’t found answers elsewhere, I would highly recommend!Would give 0 stars if I could. Doctor Carpentier is a quack who has no idea what he’s doing - from ordering wrong lab tests to wrong dosing of medication. Go ANYWHERE else if you…Would give 0 stars if I could. Doctor Carpentier is a quack who has no idea what he’s doing - from ordering wrong lab tests to wrong dosing of medication. Go ANYWHERE else if you value your health.Best place. Worth the hour drive. The first doctor to figure out what was wrong with me after 8 doctors previously saw me. A surgery and 6 months later we got pregnant without…Best place. Worth the hour drive. The first doctor to figure out what was wrong with me after 8 doctors previously saw me. A surgery and 6 months later we got pregnant without even trying! This place is filled with similar stories. Thank you!Her [Dr. Nolte] treatments are personalized to your particular problem...The gianna center offers an alternative to jumping straight into IVF...Dr. Nolte and the Gianna center is…Her [Dr. Nolte] treatments are personalized to your particular problem...The gianna center offers an alternative to jumping straight into IVF...Dr. Nolte and the Gianna center is a catholic women center that focus on naprotechnology methods. A lot of emphasis is placed on charting your cycles using the creighton method-which is helpful-but if you do not wish to chart your cycles in this way, then you should not go there. Dr. Nolte takes time to come to the underlying root cause of infertility, doing more extensive testing compared to other more larger fertility centers I have been too.Dr. Nolte always spends a generous amount of time without patients while somehow managing to stay on schedule. She is compassionate and truly worked with my goals ... She reviews…Dr. Nolte always spends a generous amount of time without patients while somehow managing to stay on schedule. She is compassionate and truly worked with my goals ... She reviews patients charts (the Creighton model of natural family planning is used at this particular center) extensively, making modifications to treatments as needed. She is patient, thorough, helpful, supportive and spends a lot of time educating patients...She helped me carefully evaluate surgeons for the excision of endometriosis, not pressuring me at all to choose her partnerCharting using the Creighton Fertility Care Model and monitoring hormone levels and follicle growth in conjunction with the chart. Dr. Nolte then only treats what appears to need…Charting using the Creighton Fertility Care Model and monitoring hormone levels and follicle growth in conjunction with the chart. Dr. Nolte then only treats what appears to need treatment. This approach is more conservative than some doctors and works with a woman's natural fertility.... She is very thorough and kind! She took the time to observe and respond to things that other doctors had looked over. She considered me as a full partner in my treatment and respected my questions, concerns and suggestions.Dr Nolte is extremely caring compassionate and knowledgeable. She clearly has a passion for her work and I have never had a more empathetic Doctor. She was a true partner in the…Dr Nolte is extremely caring compassionate and knowledgeable. She clearly has a passion for her work and I have never had a more empathetic Doctor. She was a true partner in the process....There is a lot of work involved in learning to chart appropriately and to some degree you need to let go and trust the process (particularly as the methods are a bit unorthodox). But it is so worth it!Who you would meet
Clinic route
Questions for your first conversation
Use the clinic profile to understand access, monitoring, transfer planning, and the handoff points that need agency, legal, escrow, and insurance coordination.
Get planning help-
Clinic intake
Confirm current intake requirements, accepted case types, and coordination contacts.
-
Medical screening
Ask which records, clearances, monitoring visits, and carrier-screening steps are required before transfer planning.
-
Embryo transfer
Ask how they time transfer and who they need on the care team.
-
Care-team handoff
Sequence attorney, agency, escrow, and insurance review before transfer timing creates pressure.
Patriot can help map this clinic into the full route, including legal timing, carrier coordination, escrow, insurance review, and next-step readiness.
Nearby
Other listings nearby
Fertility clinic
RMA of New York - Long Island IVF
Melville, NY · Long Island · (631) 752-0606
Jenna Friedenthal, Lucky Sekhon
Google Business Profile 3.8/5 (70 reviews) · As of May 30, 2026

Fertility clinic
NYU Langone Reproductive Specialists of New York
Mineola, NY · New York City · (516) 739-2100
Google Business Profile 3.3/5 (65 reviews) · As of May 30, 2026

Fertility clinic
Maze Men's Sexual & Reproductive Health
Harrison, NY · (646) 380-2600
Google Business Profile 4.9/5 (89 reviews) · As of May 30, 2026

Next step
Get planning help
Share a short note. We’ll keep this provider and state attached so the conversation stays on your route.
Provider
Gianna Center - Manhattan
Role
Fertility clinic
State
New York
Area
Long Island
Something look off?
Send a short note
Hours and intake change. Confirm with them before you plan around this page.